Moreton's Studio Whiteboard
Another Heuristic Interiority of Doing ~ Thinking ~ Making
From clutterings towards spatial movements and affective atmospheres of inquiry and study.
Handwritten notes and annotations, diagrams, passwords, page numbers, kiln data.
Consistancy
Diffractive (close) Readings
Practice, Design, Theory,
Apparatuses
Fictioning,
Reading,
Embodying,
Inhabiting,
Folding, Lightness,
Quickness,
Exactitude,
Visibility,
Multiplicity,
Architectural Humanities Research Association
Axisweb,
Curator Space,
Blogger,
Wordpress,
Academia.
Ceramics Now
Making Bisquit Firing
Moreton wants to develop these soundings, from clutterings into spatial movements and affective atmospheres of inquiry and study (Manning and Ingold, Barad and others).
I think the whiteboard is particularly important because it gives us another kind of interiority within Moreton's spatial practice. It is not a ceramic interior, nor an architectural chamber, but a working interiority of thought: a surface on which different activities, times, materials and propositions are brought into proximity.
What appears initially as cluttering might be understood as an emerging spatial apparatus. Handwritten notes, annotations, diagrams, passwords, page numbers, kiln data, institutional references and theoretical propositions are not simply accumulated information. They are different kinds of material, each with its own tempo, purpose and capacity to redirect attention.
The whiteboard becomes a place where thinking is spatially organised without being completely ordered. Its contents are provisional, overlapping, sometimes inconsistent, and capable of being re-entered. This is important: the whiteboard does not merely record what Moreton already knows. It participates in the production of what he might come to know.
I would develop this as a companion text to Troubling About 091126. The ceramic chamber and the studio whiteboard become two different but corresponding forms of interiority: one materially persistent, the other provisionally inscribed. Both gather, withdraw, expose and enable further relations.
The studio whiteboard offers another kind of interiority within Moreton's spatial practice. It is an active surface of inscription, annotation, provisional arrangement and return. Handwritten notes, diagrams, page numbers, passwords, kiln data, references, institutional names and fragments of theoretical thought gather upon it. Different kinds of information occupy the same field, not necessarily in agreement, nor arranged according to a predetermined hierarchy.
At first glance, this might appear as cluttering: an accumulation of unfinished thoughts, practical reminders, references and working propositions. But perhaps the cluttering is doing something. Could it be understood as a heuristic spatial condition, an interiority through which different movements of inquiry are brought into proximity?
The whiteboard is not simply a place where the practice is managed. It is one of the places where the practice becomes possible.
Its inscriptions are not all of the same order. A kiln temperature belongs to the immediate material demands of firing; a page number returns to a reading; a diagram proposes a spatial relationship; an institutional name suggests a possible field of encounter; a password provides access to another research environment. These different inscriptions have different temporalities and intensities. Some demand immediate action, others remain dormant until something else brings them back into focus.
Their proximity is productive. A practical instruction may sit beside a philosophical proposition. A ceramic firing may be thought alongside a text on affect. An application deadline may become entangled with a question about architectural humanities. A drawing, a reading or a material event may unexpectedly find another point of correspondence.
The whiteboard becomes a surface of possible re-entry.
1. Cluttering as a heuristic condition
Rather than understanding clutter as the opposite of organisation, Moreton might approach it as a provisional condition of research. Its apparent disorder holds together different kinds of activity without requiring them to become immediately consistent.
This is not an argument against consistency. Consistency is important, but perhaps it needs to be understood differently: not as the elimination of difference, nor as the imposition of a singular method, but as the continuing capacity to return to, connect and develop propositions across different situations.
A practice acquires consistency through its movements of inquiry. Ideas return, but they do not necessarily return unchanged. They are affected by new materials, readings, conversations, gestures and spatial encounters.
The whiteboard makes this process visible. It holds together what has been thought, what is being done and what might yet be undertaken.
It is a heuristic interiority because it does not simply contain knowledge. It helps produce the conditions through which knowledge can emerge.
2. The whiteboard as an apparatus
The notion of an apparatus offers a useful way of thinking about this working surface. Rather than treating it as a neutral background upon which information is displayed, we can consider how its arrangements actively organise attention, action and possible relations.
An apparatus here is not simply a tool. It is a provisional gathering of materials, practices, inscriptions, technologies, habits and situations through which particular kinds of thinking and making become possible.
The whiteboard brings together:
Practice: the immediate activities of making, drawing, constructing and firing.
Design: the provisional organisation of spatial, material and visual propositions.
Theory: readings, concepts, questions and speculative vocabularies.
Apparatuses: the tools, platforms, diagrams, annotations and working arrangements that support inquiry.
Fictioning: the capacity to propose other situations, possible architectures and ways of inhabiting.
Reading: the return of texts, images and references into the material situation of the studio.
Embodying: the translation of thought into gesture, pressure, movement and material encounter.
Inhabiting: the making of spaces in which thinking and doing become situated.
Folding: the bringing together of different times, materials, disciplines and situations without collapsing their differences.
These are not stages in a linear process. They are overlapping activities, continually affecting one another.
The apparatus is therefore less a fixed arrangement than a changing spatial ecology. Its function is not to produce a predetermined outcome, but to make new relations available.
3. Diffractive readings: bringing differences into correspondence
Moreton's interest in diffractive or close readings offers another way to understand the whiteboard's activity.
A close reading attends to the particularities of a text, image or material encounter. A diffractive reading, drawing on Karen Barad, asks how different readings and material practices make differences through their relations. It does not simply compare two independent positions or seek to reconcile them into agreement.
For Moreton, this opens the possibility of reading across studio activity, architectural propositions, ceramic processes, philosophical texts and lived situations without making them equivalent.
Ingold's correspondence, Manning's thinking through movement and Barad's intra-action can each enter the studio as different intellectual propositions. They need not become a single theoretical system. Their differences matter. Their concepts can touch, trouble and redirect one another through the particular demands of making.
A reading of Ingold might return through the hand's encounter with clay. Manning might open a question about the movement of thought through gesture. Barad might trouble the assumption that the maker, material and apparatus exist as entirely separate entities before their encounter.
The resulting reading is not simply an explanation of these thinkers. It becomes a further material and spatial inquiry.
The whiteboard can therefore be understood as a diffractive surface: a place where readings, gestures, materials and propositions encounter one another and produce differences that may not have been anticipated.
4. Lightness, quickness, exactitude, visibility and multiplicity
It is interesting that Moreton's whiteboard also gathers the five qualities identified by Italo Calvino in Six Memos for the Next Millennium: lightness, quickness, exactitude, visibility and multiplicity.
These can become more than literary qualities. They might operate as working dispositions within a spatial practice.
Lightness is not the absence of material weight or seriousness. It is the capacity to move between propositions without becoming fixed by any one of them. A drawing, a note or a material gesture can remain provisional and open to alteration.
Quickness concerns the speed of association, the unexpected return of a reading, the movement from a practical observation towards a speculative proposition. It is not simply working faster, but recognising the kairotic moment when something becomes available for further action.
Exactitude offers a necessary resistance to vagueness. It attends to the particularity of materials, processes, temperatures, dimensions, words and gestures. Exactitude does not eliminate speculation; it gives speculation something to work against.
Visibility concerns what can be made perceptible. The whiteboard makes fragments of the practice visible to itself. Diagrams, annotations and arrangements expose relations that might otherwise remain dispersed across memory, reading and studio activity.
Multiplicity allows different lines of inquiry to remain active together. Practice, design, theory, ceramics, architecture, institutional activity and philosophical reading do not need to be reduced to a single disciplinary identity.
Together, these five qualities suggest an atmosphere of study: mobile but attentive, speculative but exacting, provisional yet capable of sustained development.
5. The studio as an architecture of study
The whiteboard also opens a larger question about the studio itself.
Could the studio be understood as an architecture of study, rather than simply a place where artworks are produced?
Its activities extend beyond the immediate physical space of making. Reading, writing, drawing, firing, documenting, applying, publishing, corresponding and exhibiting are all part of its spatial life.
The studio is folded into other environments:
The Architectural Humanities Research Association, as a possible field of disciplinary correspondence.
Axisweb and CuratorSpace, as spaces of artistic presentation and professional encounter.
Blogger and WordPress, as evolving research archives and publishing environments.
Academia, as a space for the circulation of longer-form research and theoretical propositions.
Ceramics Now, as a context in which the sensate and material conditions of ceramic practice can be brought into wider conversation.
These are not simply external platforms or administrative obligations. They are different environments in which the practice becomes situated, exposed, interpreted and potentially transformed.
The studio therefore exceeds its physical boundaries. It becomes a distributed architecture of inquiry, folding different sites of learning, making and communication into its ongoing activity.
This does not mean that every platform or institution is interchangeable. Each has its own expectations, structures and power relations. Their differences need to remain visible. The task is to find ways of moving between them without allowing their disciplinary or institutional demands to determine the entire character of the practice.
6. Making, bisque, firing: the material time of inquiry
Alongside these theoretical and institutional movements sits the immediate material sequence:
Making ~ Bisque ~ Firing.
This simple notation is important. It returns the whiteboard to the material demands of the ceramic studio.
Making is not an abstract proposition. It involves clay, moisture, weight, plasticity, construction, drying, vulnerability and the changing capacities of a material body.
Bisque firing introduces another condition. The clay is transformed, its former plasticity withdrawn, while its porous body remains available for subsequent treatment.
Further surface applications, including alumina and other slips or coatings, enter into this changed material condition. The final firing produces further transformations that cannot simply be understood as the execution of an already completed design.
The material process has its own temporalities, resistances and uncertainties. It can interrupt the plans recorded on the whiteboard. A firing may produce an unexpected surface; a material failure may redirect a construction; an accidental deposit may become the beginning of another inquiry.
The whiteboard and the ceramic therefore participate in a reciprocal movement. The whiteboard proposes, records and redirects. The ceramic responds, resists, persists and makes other questions possible.
One is an inscriptive working surface; the other is a materially transformed body. Both are involved in the continuing production of knowledge.
7. From clutterings towards affective atmospheres of study
Perhaps the most interesting question is how these different activities begin to acquire an atmosphere.
Affect, understood through Spinoza's account of the capacities to affect and be affected, helps to describe this movement. The studio is not simply filled with information or objects. It is a changing field of capacities, intensities and possible actions.
A handwritten note can redirect attention. A diagram can produce a spatial proposition. A reading can make an existing material process appear differently. A firing can interrupt an assumption. A conversation can return as a gesture several weeks later.
These events do not have to share the same origin or purpose to become consequential to one another.
The atmosphere of study emerges through their relations: the pressures, attractions, interruptions, hesitations and intensifications that make certain possibilities more available than others.
This is where the idea of weather-worlding becomes useful. The studio is not sealed off from the changing conditions of life. It is continually affected by external situations, institutional demands, environmental conditions, readings, conversations and material encounters.
Its interiority is permeable.
The whiteboard becomes a small weather system of inquiry: a surface upon which different forces gather, change direction, disappear from immediate attention and return in another form.
8. Towards a heuristic spatial practice
Moreton's heuristic spatial practice does not seek to resolve its different activities into a unified method. It seeks to sustain their capacity to affect one another.
The whiteboard is one of its working interiors, but the practice also finds other interiors in ceramic chambers, research archives, reading environments, diagrams, publications and exhibition spaces.
Each offers a different condition for thinking and making. Each has its own materiality, temporality and degree of withdrawal.
The challenge is to develop a consistency of practice without collapsing these differences. To allow theory to touch material activity without turning the ceramic into an illustration of theory. To allow making to generate thought without claiming that every material event already contains a complete philosophical explanation. To allow institutional and disciplinary encounters to inform the practice without prescribing its future direction.
The studio whiteboard, in this sense, is not a plan for the practice. It is a provisional architecture through which the practice continues to find its way.
Its clutterings are not simply waiting to be tidied into order. They are waiting to be sounded, touched, read, folded and re-entered.
The whiteboard is a surface of becoming: a heuristic interiority in which doing, thinking and making gather into affective atmospheres of inquiry.
Developing the whiteboard into a research apparatus
I would retain the original list, but begin to understand it as several overlapping spatial movements. This gives you a way to work with the whiteboard rather than simply transcribe it.
The studio's five working fields
01 · Conceptual field
Practice ~ Design ~ Theory
The ongoing negotiation between making, spatial propositions and speculative thought.
02 · Research apparatus
Apparatuses ~ Fictioning ~ Reading
The devices, texts, diagrams and speculative propositions through which inquiry is generated.
03 · Embodied field
Embodying ~ Inhabiting ~ Folding
The movement of thought into gesture, material, spatial experience and situated relations.
04 · Aesthetic dispositions
Lightness ~ Quickness ~ Exactitude ~ Visibility ~ Multiplicity
Calvino's qualities as practical dispositions for attending, composing and making.
05 · Material time
Making ~ Bisque ~ Firing
The particular material conditions, transformations and resistances through which ceramic thinking takes place.
These fields are not a hierarchy. They are different entrances into the same working ecology. The institutional and publishing environments — AHRA, Axisweb, CuratorSpace, Blogger, WordPress, Academia and Ceramics Now — can be understood as further sites into which the studio's thinking travels and from which it returns.
A further proposition: consistency without sameness
I would make this a central question in the ongoing research:
How does a spatial practice develop consistency through the continual movement of differences, rather than through their resolution?
This is where Ingold, Manning and Barad can be brought into a productive, but not homogenised, correspondence:
Ingold: making as correspondence, attending to materials and following their lines of becoming.
Manning: thought as movement, and the eventful emergence of possibilities through practice.
Barad: intra-action, where relations are not simply established between already independent entities, but participate in the emergence of differences and boundaries.
They do not say the same thing. Their differences are precisely what make the reading productive. Moreton's practice can give these propositions a material situation in which they are tested, troubled and altered.
I would also retain one particular phrase from your notes: “another kind of heuristic interiorities of doing~thinking~making.” It is important because it allows the whiteboard, ceramic chamber and studio itself to be understood as related but different interiors.
Perhaps the emerging research proposition is:
The studio is not simply where Moreton makes. It is an architecture of study in which making, reading, thinking and inhabiting become mutually affecting movements of inquiry.
And the whiteboard is one of its most revealing surfaces: not a map of an already established practice, but a place where the practice is still becoming possible.
One useful next development would be to make a companion post titled “The Studio as an Architecture of Study: Apparatuses, Fictioning and the Weather-World of Making”, allowing this whiteboard enquiry to open into your larger research on speculative learning and spatial practice.

No comments:
Post a Comment