Sunday, 22 November 2026

The Troubled Hospitality of Interiority : Hortus Conclusus ~ Indexical Bodies ~ Diffractive Hospitality

Hortus Conclusus ~ Indexical Bodies ~ Diffractive Hospitality

What kinds of bodies can gather a place, and what forms of alienation must remain possible for that gathering to stay open?

The Troubled Hospitality of Interiority

The hortus conclusus remains a significant body within Moreton’s spatial practice because it offers an early proposition concerning the relation between enclosure, sensory experience, contemplation and care. Revisited through Diffraction~Hospitality~Alienation~Atmosphere, however, the sheltered garden becomes more than an image of protected intimacy. It becomes a situated condition through which the limits and responsibilities of hospitality can be examined.

The garden gathers, but does not escape the differences through which its interiority is established. It shelters, but cannot wholly determine the relations that enter its boundaries. Its atmosphere emerges through bodies and processes that exceed the intentions of its cultivation. The sheltered place is therefore hospitable without being entirely knowable.

The withdrawn ceramic body carries this difficulty into another material register. It persists without closing its spatial proposition, offering a body through which intimacy, resistance and indeterminacy may become consequential. Its chamber is neither wholly enclosed nor entirely open; it gathers relations without resolving their differences.

Moreton’s spatial inquiry develops through this correspondence between situated bodies. The earlier garden and the later ceramic chamber remain materially and conceptually distinct, yet each allows the other to be encountered otherwise. The spatial matrix does not provide a final synthesis. It sustains the conditions through which these bodies can continue to trouble and extend one another.

The proposition is therefore not simply that a place should be hospitable. It is that hospitality becomes spatially consequential when it remains responsive to the alienation, difference and more-than-human material relations that its gathering cannot fully resolve.

The sheltered place persists, but its interiority remains in formation. It gathers bodies without possessing them, sustains intimacy without guaranteeing familiarity, and remains open to the atmospheric indeterminacies through which further spatial propositions may emerge.







The hortus conclusus returns as a situated body of inquiry, encountered now through other indexical~sensate bodies. The garden's earlier propositions of enclosure, cultivation, intimacy and care are neither preserved unchanged nor displaced. They are diffracted through material encounters in which bodily presence becomes uncertain, surfaces retain traces of contact, and interiors emerge through relations between bodies.

In the dispersed figure, petals, pigment and linear marks trouble the body's apparent limits. Organic matter becomes detached from its originating body, entering another material arrangement. Presence persists through dispersal; the body remains perceptible while becoming unfamiliar to itself. In the perforated ceramic bodies, enclosure acquires another condition. Weathered surfaces retain the traces of making, while apertures and the interval between forms allow a chamber to emerge through proximity rather than containment.

Hospitality becomes inseparable from this troubling of bodily identity. To receive another body is not necessarily to assimilate it, nor to guarantee its belonging. The hosted body may remain unfamiliar, resistant or only partially available. Alienation therefore does not simply oppose hospitality; it marks the difference that hospitality must encounter without resolving. Diffraction keeps these relations active, allowing the garden, the image, the ceramic and the reading body to enter correspondence without converging upon a single account of interiority.

Atmosphere emerges through this correspondence as a sensate condition of material and spatial exchange. It gathers through surfaces, apertures, colour, light, organic traces, proximity and the movements of attention. The interior is no longer understood solely as a protected space within an enclosing boundary. It becomes a provisional condition continually produced and troubled through relations with other bodies.

The hortus conclusus is thus revisited not as an image of enclosed harmony, but as a persistent spatial proposition. Its questions of shelter and intimacy remain in play, acquiring further capacities through bodies that disperse, receive, resist and endure. What persists is not a completed meaning of the garden, but the possibility of encountering its relations otherwise.

Working with one's hands, cultivating the earth within sheltered spaces, becomes a shared pastoral practice that binds people to place. Zumthor reinforces this pastoral character by placing a pavilion at the centre of the garden. He imagines it as a place for future gatherings and quiet contemplation, anticipating "the natural energy and beauty of the tableau vivant of grasses, flowers and shrubs. I am looking forward to the colours and shapes, the smell of the soil, the movement of the leaves" (Zumthor 2011: 15). The garden is therefore experienced not only visually but through the full range of the senses. Elizabeth Knox's The Vintner's Luck similarly evokes an intimate relationship between landscape and human experience. The taste of wine becomes inseparable from the soil that produced it; earth and wine are of the same substance, united by locality and landscape. Moreton finds this set of references particularly rich for his evolving spatial matrix, earth becomes clay that works amongst hospitality and alienation, an awkwardness of becoming with other situated bodies. 


I think the richness lies in the movement from cultivating the earth to becoming with earth. The pastoral is not simply a theme of the garden, nor a harmonious relation between people and nature. It is a situated practice through which bodies become attached to place by working with matter, responding to its resistances and participating in its transformations.

Zumthor's pavilion anticipates future gatherings, but the garden's life cannot be prescribed in advance. Grasses, flowers and shrubs will grow, change colour, release their smells and move with the air. The pavilion offers a place from which these changes might be encountered, while the garden itself exceeds the pavilion's capacity to frame them. Hospitality here is a material and sensate condition: a place becomes hospitable through the relations it makes possible, rather than through enclosure alone.

Knox's The Vintner's Luck introduces a further intimacy. Wine does not merely signify a landscape; its taste makes the earth perceptible through another body. Soil, vine, fruit, labour, fermentation and locality enter into a material correspondence. The earth is not left behind in the finished wine. It persists differently, transformed through a series of situated encounters.

Clay offers a particularly productive hinge between these propositions. It is earth worked by hand, but it is also earth that resists the hand's intention. Its plasticity permits shaping; its weight, moisture, drying, fracture and firing introduce conditions that cannot be wholly determined by the maker. Working with clay is therefore neither the imposition of form upon passive matter nor a simple return to the earth. It is an awkward practice of becoming with material whose capacities and limits participate in what the work can become.

For Moreton  the spatial matrix of Diffraction~Hospitality~Alienation~Atmosphere, and its awkwardness becomes generative.

Hospitality names the willingness of a situated body to enter relations with other bodies, materials and conditions of place.

Alienation marks the difference that persists within those relations: earth does not become clay without transformation, and clay does not become ceramic without undergoing a change that withdraws it from its earlier condition.

Diffraction names how these encounters alter the propositions they carry. The garden, wine, earth, hand and ceramic do not converge upon a single account of place; they bring different material histories into correspondence.

Atmosphere emerges through their sensate exchange: soil, smell, moisture, colour, touch, light, temperature and the temporalities of growth, making and firing.

The pastoral for him therefore becomes more than a shared practice that binds people to place. It offers a way to consider how place is continually made and unmade through material participation, while remaining more than any one body can gather or know.

Working with one's hands, cultivating the earth within sheltered spaces, becomes a shared pastoral practice that binds people to place. Yet this attachment is not simply a matter of belonging. It develops through the material encounters by which bodies become involved in the ongoing life of a place.

Zumthor's pavilion anticipates future gatherings and quiet contemplation, opening the garden to the changing colours, smells, movements and textures of its living matter. Its hospitality lies not only in the shelter it provides, but in the sensate relations it makes possible. The garden exceeds the pavilion, just as its atmosphere exceeds any singular experience of it.

Elizabeth Knox's The Vintner's Luck offers another register of this situated intimacy. Wine and soil become inseparable through the transformations that connect earth, vine, fruit, labour and locality. The earth persists within the wine, not as an unchanged substance but through a material correspondence that allows landscape to be encountered otherwise.

These propositions acquire another intensity through clay. Earth becomes a material with which the hand works, but never simply a passive substance awaiting form. Clay offers resistance, plasticity and transformation; it registers touch while exceeding the intentions that touch brings to it. Making becomes an awkward practice of becoming with other situated bodies, in which intimacy does not dissolve difference and hospitality cannot guarantee belonging.

Within this spatial matrix, earth~clay becomes a troubled body of correspondence. It gathers the pastoral intimacies of cultivation and place while introducing the alienation of material transformation. The hand does not simply shape the earth; it enters a relation through which both the material proposition and the maker's understanding of it may change. Firing extends this relation into the persistence of ceramic, carrying the encounter forward without preserving it intact.

Diffraction~Hospitality~Alienation~Atmosphere thus offers a means of reconsidering the pastoral beyond an ideal of sheltered harmony. Place becomes a sensate and material gathering in which bodies may enter correspondence without becoming identical. The hospitable place is not one in which difference disappears, but one in which difference can remain active, felt and capable of further transformation.

The key conceptual shift found here for Moreton it that he moves from the earth as something that binds people to place towards earth~clay as a body through which place, making and belonging are continually negotiated. It brings Moreton's earlier pastoral research into direct correspondence with the ceramic practice without making the ceramics a representation of the garden.


Speculative Projective Reading/Making : Life outside the circle of architecture

In troubled times they all sought to experience life away from social definitions of success or failure. From there, these primitive huts marked personal, original inquires into the ever-mysterious nature of human existence.

Anne Cline. A Hut of One’s Own
Life Outside The Circle Of Architecture.













The realisation of my interiors project consists of two separate but relational elements that are presented into a built environment. The small ‘Scriptorium’ conceived as a space as a refuge, an intimate minimal construction that features a doorway and an interior that contains a place for objects, perhaps books, as well as a small sitting area. 
This construction, an open cell perhaps is evocative to a state of contemplation between the fabric of the everyday. The rather hybrid design appropriates a merging of minimalism, modernism and the plastic architecture of a ruined Cistercian Abbey. The construction comes into close contact with its occupant, it is a restricted spatial apparatus that attempts to promote through its awkwardness distinctive experiences. In particular the apparatus of the Scriptorium and its materiality is attempting to promote a sensory intensification that is further underpinned by the cognitive processes of reading and perhaps other social dialogues. The sensory intensification of a hut like space promotes a haptic sensibility, allowing the nearness and intimacies of both the built space and the imaginative, virtual realm to become entangled. 
Ultimately the Scriptorium is trying to build on unique human subjectivities that are manifested through a kinaesthetic repertoire or script that helps to enact further spatial experiences. It might be useful to think of this constructed space as itself still under construction, a site that acts as its own vessel within the multiplicities of human perception itself. The influence of the Cistercian Order, the site of Waverly Abbey and its pastoral landscape, have all contributed to a sense of the design process, The Scriptorium like the ruins themselves is open to the elements. Waverley Abbey remains as a sensory site between the remains of architecture and its society and the effects of our own global culture in the information age.



Spatial Practice could be a program and a site for a critical approach to social engagement and interdisciplinary collaboration.

A HUT WITHIN THE INFLUENCE AND NATURE OF ARCHITECTURE 

The tendency of technological culture to standardize environmental condition and make
the environment entirely predictable is causing a serious sensory impoverishment. Our buildings have lost their opacity and depth, sensory invitation and discovery, mystery and shadow.
Juhani Pallasmaa. Hapticity and Time. Notes on Fragile Architecture. 2000 

The Scriptorium
Description of Work

The ruined site of the abbey at Waverley, near Farnham has been appropriated as a site and as a place within which to position and develop architectural and sociological inquires. The design processes of interiors have been employed as a tool to both critique and to create how we might further develop the contents of architecture. This Spatiality and its diffractions of differences and similarities, narratives and subjective experiences are what my interior spaces attempt to initiate.
Design as a interactive structure, an interlocutory interior in the making of space and spatial relations.
Interior design presented as an interactive and immersive spatial inquiry
The Scriptorium brings together a varied and discursive set of objects, texts and interior architectures. This work seeks to understand how the virtual changes physical
architecture and how this affects the space between people and buildings. The
“performativity of research" is presented through specifically designed apparatuses and partitions. These designed components, made objects together with annotated texts and drawings conspire to create a complex design led inquiry a “Place Study” staged in a niche-like space. This interior presents itself as both distinct and relational to the other projects in the MA Interiors Show. The interior presents the many manifestations of creative research, structures and even symposia that have been developed through engaging with the site. The visualization of the research and the relational architectures rendered through montage and collage explores digital and analogue technologies. This hybridisation and the use of pinhole photography and film footage further explore interests in the field of performance as an immaterial architecture drawn in the presence of place.

Praxis could be the energy produced between combining research and creative embodiment as speculative strategies/assemblages.










The Reading Room
Materials and Objects in Social Space
Spatial Practices in The Politics of Things


'Ordinary things contain the deepest mysteries'

The Social Condenser in Operation.
Five figures and a stature distributed evenly in its isotropic space; a picture of the socialized as opposed to the sociable.

Robin Evans,
Figures, Doors and Passages

Project Proposal Waverley Abbey Site 2014.

Exploratory project centred around the proposal to return the site with its Cistercian origins and its surviving ruins into a self sustaining pastoral and educational retreat.

Secular Retreat, Peter Zumthor
 
Krishnamurti Centre

Brockwood Park School, Holistic, Sustainable, Education.

This site requires a new working order much the same in stature as before its dissolution. This holistically based institute would operate as both a learning centre with research facilities and practical workshops that would facilitate in the development and maintenance of the site and its structures.
It is envisaged that new enclosures will articulate the project space as a whole and help to regenerate this once prolific pastoral community. The choice of materials and building practices is being reviewed and extended to allow the hybridising of the vernacular with the technological advancements of new building processes and materials. The new structures built into the existing site will mutually accommodate any existing feature or surface.

The scaffolding systems of construction will inform the envelope of the internal frames and built components will be incorporated as single spatial entities within the headroom of the structure. The seductive densities of materials and substances will theatrically inform space and surfaces.
Rooms can become thematic, theorised even through their content of substances, materiality, space and ambient light.

It is a design feature that these new adaptations for dwelling spaces should in some way index and register the spaces that have been erased by a process of over writing in the sense of a double occupancy, a place reopened back to a site. New surfaces become facsimiles of existing forms (use of clay impressions as floors) from which to create within the building a series of subtle palimpsests.
Spaces become fused with the monumentality of the existing historical remnants. Corridors navigate both the passage of individuals and the interventions that set-up possibilities for spaces between walls and floors.

The adaptation of this ruinous mass of historical architectural forms becomes enmeshed through sensitive and site responsive adaptations; living architectures that can playfully through a vocational necessity that (a being close at hand) crafts evocative, poignant and precise interior spaces.



Photographic Collage with text fragments and disparate images










Originally published 14 February 2017, revisited 2021 

Saturday, 21 November 2026

Inside Phenomena : Innerness and Interior : Material Matters

Theory and Analysis.
Architecture and Material Practice.

Katie Lloyd Thomas.
Material Matters : Architecture and Material Practice.

Hylomorphism which understands materials as a subset of matter, does not provide a way of positively distinguishing materials, and underscores the architectural tendency to use materials as mere finishes, exchangeable and superficial. In turn it is no surprise that materials become supplementary in architecture and are used to decorate or to signify.

Gaston Bachelard is a rare example of a philosopher concerned with this problem. Not only is he aware of philosophy's tendency to privilege form over matter, he raises the question of individuation: I was immediately struck by the neglect of the material cause in aesthetic philosophy. In particular it seemed to me that the individualizing power of matter had been underestimated. Why does everyone always associate the notion of the individual with form?
Gaston Bachelard, Water and Dreams: An Essay on the Imagination of Matter.
 





Russell Moreton
MA Interiors.
UCA Farnham. 2014

In the future will we be able to extract the Platonic values that Hans Coper writes about with regard to the Egyptian vessel?

This essay is an attempt to get to understand my current concerns centred around the interior spaces of things and places. This sense of the interior is itself held in place by the notion of some kind of vessel or material whether it is a pot or an architectural structure. It is this vessel and its materiality together with its form and its formlessness that I want to explore more closely.
In architecture an interior can become a ‘sensing space’ with its own particular characteristics it becomes a host space, an extension of our own existential space; it can promote memories, sensations and can act as a reflective refuge from our post modern lives. Do these vessels and spaces re-enact the particulars of traditions and livelihoods, of other lives; are they in fact built expressions on the basic needs of a civilisation whether they be pots or architecture?
Do we in some way attempt to reconcile and balance opposites, the outside with the inside; and as a result the practicality of a space depends on a larger degree to issues regarding its actual emptiness? I am interested in both the interior of a vessel, and the interior sensations of being in a space. The Poetics of Space by Gaston Bachelard is also interested in this dialectic between ‘inside’ and ‘outside’.

In her essay The Essential Vessel, Natasha Daintry (Daintry, 2007:9) cites The Tao Te Ching ‘we turn clay to make a vessel, but it is on the space where there is nothing that the usefulness of the vessel depends.’ It follows then that this might be where the vessel starts to embody ‘something and nothing and becomes an effortless three dimensional manifestation of both form and formlessness.’ (Daintry,2007, :8) It is interesting to note that the potter is dealing simultaneously with both form and its attendant space as he hollows out the clay to create what might be termed an ‘essay to abstraction, a clothing of emptiness.’(Daintry,2007:8) This defined air is the ‘most transcendently human of all made things; volume, inner space, an interior, the carved out air that connects the morning teacup with the domes and spandrels of San Maco. There’s nothing there but clay and air, then there’s defined air.’(Gopnik, 2014:6) Adam Gopnik essay on the pots of Edmund de Waal speaks of an ‘innerness’ and De Waal speaks of ‘a breath held inward’. My own experience of De Waals work in the Architects House at Roche Court, Salisbury, is that of a multitude of similar porcelain pots that were all uniquely able to hold just a single thought or a memory. The installed pots and their simple wooden support became a permeable wall for remembered silences.
This sentiment and its sensitivity to describing visible aspects of the world that are conjoining the concrete with emptiness becomes a poetic on the permeability of spaces and their vessels. The philosopher, Lucretius who was interested in infinitesimal entities comments in his poetic work ‘On the Nature of Things’ records how ‘knowledge of the world tends to dissolve the solidity of the world.’(Daintry, 2007:8) This lightness and its associative attendances can be found in ‘Hans Coper’s only extant piece of writing.’(DeWaal, 2004:34)

A pre-dynastic Egyptian pot, roughly egg-shaped, the size of my hand made thousands of years ago, possibly by a slave, it has survived in more than one sense. A humble, passive, somehow absurd object – yet potent, mysterious, sensuous. It conveys no comment, no self expression, but it seems to contain and reflect its maker and the human world it inhabits, to contribute its minute quantum of energy – and homage. Hans Coper, 1969.

Does Hans Coper’s text reflect through this archaic pot the human sense of innerness that this vessel still dwells with? ‘Theories of relativity and uncertainty have shown that all matter, even the airy oxygenated void inside a vessel is energy, and that it is composed of the same building blocks generated from exploded stars.’ (Daintry, 2007:8) Hans Coper’s Egyptian pot certainly as he observes, is still contributing its minute quantum of energy from thousands of years ago; an innerness put into being by the human hand. The sensing, doing and being that is caught, even marooned in this vessel talks of existential states, rituals, of things that shift and move as you inhabit the interlockingness of skin, volume and displacement.
There is a material memory at work here, an artefact from another epoch, another mindset, but our corporality and the physical traces left in the clay concur its humanity. Pottery is given a priority in its ability to reveal cultures of the past.
‘The special historical value of pottery is due to its stillness underground. Almost uniquely, it does not corrode or disintegrate when exposed to earth and water, and so it forms the most important part of the physical record of the past. Like an invisible architecture, inverted and buried out of sight, they are our most reliable evidence of human endeavour.’ (Adamson, 2009:36)

Gaston Bachelard writes in his Poetics of Space that ‘We absorb a mixture of being and nothingness.’ He is interested in the dialectic of ‘outside’ and ‘inside’. He asks is outside vast and fluid and inside concrete and small? He surmises that perhaps there is some membrane or intermediate surface that could separate the two states or rather a duality of ‘outside’ and ‘inside’. But these are concepts and abstractions, ‘the real experience is more kinetic, more fluid and interchangeable.’ (Daintry,2007:11) Can it be that as Bachelard argues that the mind and its imagination actually blurs the duality of inside and outside. He comments ’everything, even size, is a human value, even the miniature can accumulate size.’ In this way he explains further ‘being does not see itself, it does not stand out, it is not bordered by nothingness: one is never sure of finding it, or of finding a solid when one approaches a centre of being. We absorb a mixture of being and nothingness.’(Bachelard,1994:53)
Bachelard seems to be in accord with the poetics of Lucretius as described by Italo Calvino in his Six Memos for the Next Millennium as ‘the poet of physical concreteness, viewed in its permanent and immutable substance, but the first thing he tells us is that emptiness is just as concrete as solid bodies.’(Calvino,1996: 61) There is a lightness and an exactitude in this ‘interior space’ that exists between its states of form and its formlessness. The vessel seems to have the ability to inhabit, mediate and transpose spaces between the ‘rich liminal territory of uncertainty and abstraction.’ (Daintry,2007:12)
The transformative power of the vessel on changing spaces and our perceptions through its existential condition is illustrated in the poem “Anecdote of the Jar by Wallace Stevens” cited by Edmund De Waal. The jar or rather its vessel qualities becomes a spatial metaphor as it ‘practices’ the landscape around it by taking dominion as it were over the unmade. Perhaps Wallace Stevens’s ‘Jar’ promotes an architecture for the soul, an intimate yet social interior illuminated through the imagination?
Natasha Daintry asks are we now using objects to lead us back to ourselves, objects that before were used as a way of feeling our way into the world? (Daintry,2007:13) She remarks on the strong resonance that clay in particular has to human civilisation and as a material that can socially inform us.
I am interested in exploring further these notions of material and spaces, of form and formlessness through the social contexts and professional practices of Hans Coper and Edmund de Waal. I am particularly interested in the making process ‘throwing’ as it promotes the situation of attending to the physicality of things which has the effect of locating you in the world and connecting you to your own physicality. Daintry comments ‘it represents a way of existence of felt experience, of being known, and knowing the world through the corporeal.’ (Daintry,2007:13)



Pottery Making, Inner Spaces, Installation Art and the Post modern.

‘When potters throw a certain curve in a vessel wall, they are in affect in dialogue with every kindred pot that they have seen or held. Like an archaeologist’s excavated shard, the experiential dimension of making can act as a bridge across temporal distances.’ (Adamson, 2009:44) The pot can be seen as a cultural trace that can bring a sense of immediacy from across the centuries.

Hans Coper’s assembled ceramics are constructed from a number of thrown components, throwing a process that he remarks on by saying ‘I become part of the process, I am learning to operate a sensitive instrument, which may be resonant to my experience of existence now.’(Birks,1983:63) Tony Birks comments that all his works were containers and that they were all thrown and that some of their energy is the direct response of being solely conceived on the wheel. This ceramic practice of throwing gave him his sense of livelihood, dwelling and skill.
Coper’s pots celebrate the studio potters pioneering spirit of innovation and discovery through the daily practice and discipline of a craft. He produced composite forms of his own invention that underpinned his modernist aesthetic. His ceramics have evolved through a series of archetypes, families and groupings, from which he could propose subtle amendments and adaptations.
Hans Coper’s pots are objects that seem to spatialize their surroundings with their complex inner spaces. They seem to set up in their interiors, narratives and intimacies that radiate outwards to the surface of the vessel and then beyond into the scale of the world.
The Pots themselves have an almost mechanical surface treatment. This is caused by abrading the glazed engobe layer. This seems to give their interior space a reverence for the handmade and sensibilities of the once plastic clay.
Hans Coper’s candlesticks made for Coventry Cathedral could be seen as epochal points of reflection and reconciliation with humanity.
His pots take up dominion as thinking, sensorial vessels, artefacts that enter into our existential social realm.
Hans Coper was part of an ethical avant-garde. He produced modernist artefacts that sat on his studio shelves; his pots had no need of biography, plinth or cabinet. They exist solely through the agency and inquiry of their makers’ situation; they reference the modernist traits of their time, yet they are touched by an archaic timelessness, an entropy that they and we can never escape. These pots now question the new social consciousness that has itself left art in the world of the Post modern, which is itself addictive, conditioned and fetishized. Hans Coper’s pots remain humble in their humility despite market forces; but can they really gives us some sense of ‘a vision that affords perspective on our existence and the hidden aspirations of man?’ (Kuspit,1994:5)
Suzi Gablik in The Re-enchantment of Art confirms that our way of thinking about art (has become conditioned) to the point where we have become incredibly addicted to certain kinds of experience at the expense of others, such as community, or ritual. Not only does the particular way of life for which we have been programmed lack any cosmic, or transpersonal dimension, but its underlying principles (have become) manic production and consumption, maximum energy flow, mind-less waste and greed. (Gablik, 1991:2)
In sharp contrast to the abraded and textured reworkings found on Hans Coper’s pots, Edmund de Waal’s contemporary installations furnished with his own hand thrown porcelain pots; shimmer and shine with a suffused surface of reflections producing a delicate aesthetic that promotes his ‘dialogue about the use, preciousness, survival, presentation and display of ceramics.’(Graves, 2008:8)
His large scale installations show large groups of ceramic vessels, these are often in historic architectural settings. He is both an artist and an historian of ceramics. His installation Signs and Wonders contains up to 425 pieces of wheel thrown porcelain. Through working with specific settings De Waal has produced installations that by their very impermanence offer ‘new and unexpected dialogues’ through staged interventions that are ‘framing pots within architectural features or the intimate spaces of furniture.’ (Graves, 2009:10) This site specific installation is located high up in and under the main oculus window at the Victoria and Albert museum in London. The installation will be visible to viewers as they look upwards into the space of the monumental central dome.
Signs and Wonders could be about seeing and sensing pots from a distance, De Waal is seeking to reflect the sentiments found in Wallace Stevens poem that makes the pot itself appear as a still centre from which we can step back from and observe as it helps us to gather in our surroundings.
‘De Waal has placed his pots in circulation, but not in the sense that they can be held and passed around. They are even, to some degree withheld.’ (Adamson, 2009:34) De Waal’s porcelain vessels (shape shifters) are in effect objects from memory brought into a shifting nature of influences from the Chinese porcelains, the 1800 Century European porcelains and the collections of the Modern era from Vienna, Bauhaus and the Constructivists. ‘The way in which the pots are displayed has become an integral part of the work. And increasingly there is a sense that it is about putting on a show, albeit one that might be for a private audience.’ (Graves, 2009:8)
This work is not about tactility, immediacy or possession, perhaps De Waal has succeeded in producing a collection that is also ‘a talisman of subjectivity’ of one man’s personal vision of ceramics.
His work and the interior spaces associated with it are in some way becoming endemic of his and our post modern world. Is there some sense that De Waal’s throwing, his vessel making has itself just become a function, an endless repetition. Is there a fear that the presentation and the framing of De Waal’s vessels actually ends up with him filling in the spaces he has strived to construct?
Although the body has been existential throughout the throwing process and is clearly represented in Edmund de Waals work. It might now appear that these new thrown pots destined for another staged presentation, are being crafted with this aim in mind.
Rebecca Solnit explores Susan Bordo’s claim that ‘if the body is a metaphor for our locatedness in space and time and thus for the finitude of human perception and knowledge, then the post modern body is no body at all.’ Solnit comments on this post modern body that it is more of a passive object, appearing most often laid out upon an examining table or in bed. ‘A medical and sexual phenomenon, it is site of sensations, processes, and desires rather than a source of action and production, this body has nothing left but the erotic as a residue of what it means to be embodied. Which is not to disparage sex and the erotic as fascinating and profound, only to propose that they are so emphasised because other aspects of being embodied have atrophied for many people.’(Solnit, 2002)

We return back to the urgent need to make and experience things that in someway that lead us back to ourselves. The creative architectural work of Peter Zumthor is something that I am engaging with. He has developed architectural design practices that consider each project in terms of a comprehensive and encompassing sensory experience. He looks beyond the mere physical form and its fabric. He attempts to address issues of the body and how it may interact within a built environment. The use of memory as a spatial narrative to accompany the atmosphere of his spaces is realised through evocative material surfaces and densities. I feel that there is a synergy here between the opening up of the interior of a pot and the opening up of a space to dwell in.
In sensing a pots interior from its surface, we are as it were in some intimate tacit correspondence with its spatial sensing centre. We become known to it through its maker’s creative gesture of innerness. This anthropological inner space linking us to the potter is both sensual and distant; its vacancy allows us dwell in the maker’s absence. We become part of the vessel, we enter its philosophy of solitude.



Making~ Transmaterialities : Research Bodies in Situation with Leper Graves

Figural : Cyanotype Process Drawings.

Moreton — making~transmaterialities: material practices give these propositions situated, sensate conditions through which they can be encountered without being reduced to illustrations of theory.

Negative Capability part I is an exhibition of visual and written responses to the University of Winchester’s Magdalen Hill Archaeological Research Project (MHARP), one of the most extensive excavations to date of a medieval leper hospital, almshouse and cemetery complex. The artists observed the excavation team at work, witnessing their process then displaying the results in the gallery and inviting writers to respond.

These inclusions sharpen the earlier reading considerably. They make explicit something that was present in the spatial gatherings but not yet fully articulated: the encounter is not primarily an exchange of meanings between already constituted bodies. It is a touching through which bodies acknowledge an elemental otherness that is also implicated in their own existence.

Zornberg's The Murmuring Deep gives this encounter a sensate and elemental register. Light, earth, air and warmth are not simply environmental conditions surrounding human experience. They are what bodies share, encounter and communicate through their situated existence. We orient one another within these elements before, or beyond, any exchange of clearly defined meanings.

Barad's Trans/Matter/Realities: Queer Political Imaginings introduces a more troubling implication. The inhuman is not safely located outside the human, as an external other that can be observed, classified or accommodated. It is already implicated in what we are and how we become. The insensible, irrational, unfathomable and incalculable are not merely limits to be overcome in the production of knowledge. They trouble the fantasy that we could ever become fully self-contained, transparent or in control.






Read together, these passages allow us to reconsider the earlier spatial gatherings as more than provisional arrangements of objects, images and architectural elements. They become situations of elemental touching in which the boundaries between bodies remain consequential but cannot be secured in advance.

The connection is particularly strong with your 2018 research situation at Open Studios Norfolk: lever graves, meadow grasses and cyanotype contact paper. Here, contact is not only an idea. It is materially enacted. Grasses touch the photosensitive surface; light participates in the exposure; the resulting image bears traces of a meeting between bodies that do not share the same material condition or agency. The image is indexical, but it does not transmit the encounter in its entirety. It carries a trace of an event whose relations exceed what the image can disclose.

This is where Making~Transmaterialities becomes more than a description of work across materials. It names a condition in which touching is simultaneously intimate and alienating: an encounter with what is related to us without being reducible to us.

The Encounter ~ Elemental Otherness ~ Queer Inhuman

The encounter rests on an acknowledgement of elemental otherness: a touching through which bodies become responsive to what is related to their own existence without becoming the same. As Zornberg suggests in The Murmuring Deep, we encounter and communicate through the light, earth, air and warmth that sustain our bodies. These elements are not simply external conditions of experience. They participate in the ways bodies orient one another, making encounter possible beyond the transmission of clear meanings.

This elemental correspondence offers a further reading of the spatial gatherings. Timber, metal, photographic images, painted surfaces, furniture, apertures and bodies do not simply occupy a common space. They participate in a material situation whose relations cannot be exhausted by identifying the elements or interpreting their arrangement. The gathering becomes a touching through which differences acquire spatial and sensate consequence.

Barad's queer inhuman intensifies this proposition. The inhuman is not a separate realm opposed to the human, but an unsettling of the boundaries through which the human is understood as autonomous, rational and self-contained. In Trans/Matter/Realities: Queer Political Imaginings (2015), indeterminacy becomes an affirmation rather than a lack: the incalculable and unfathomable are implicated in the conditions through which responsibility becomes possible. The encounter does not promise mastery over otherness. It demands an attentiveness to relations whose consequences cannot be completely known in advance.

The 2018 research situation at Open Studios Norfolk, involving lever graves, meadow grasses and cyanotype contact paper, offers a material instance of this troubling. Contact between grasses, photosensitive paper and light produces an indexical trace, but the image cannot contain the encounter from which it emerges. Its surface makes a relation perceptible while leaving much of that relation unresolved. The image persists as a body of contact, available to further encounters without becoming a transparent account of what took place.

Making~Transmaterialities therefore names an infinite touching of alterity that lives in, around and through bodies. It is not a claim that all matter becomes indistinguishable, nor that every encounter produces harmony. It is an acknowledgement that bodies are constituted and altered through relations with what they cannot wholly assimilate or know. Hospitality becomes a willingness to remain exposed to this otherness; alienation names the difference that persists within such intimacy; diffraction allows the encounter to generate further differences rather than converge upon a final meaning; and atmosphere becomes the sensate field through which these relations are felt.

The spatial proposition is consequently not a stable arrangement of bodies, nor a representation of their entanglement. It is an apparatus through which elemental, material and affective relations become available for encounter. The apparatus gathers, but cannot contain, the indeterminacy it makes perceptible. Its hospitality remains troubled; its boundaries remain consequential without being absolute.

To make, within this field, is to participate in relations whose outcomes are neither entirely given nor wholly controllable. The responsibility that follows does not arise from achieving complete knowledge of other bodies. It emerges from recognising that one's own existence is already implicated in relations with what remains unfamiliar, insensible or beyond calculation.

A distinction worth preserving

I would keep three propositions in active correspondence rather than collapse them into one:

Zornberg — elemental communication: bodies encounter and orient one another through the shared conditions of earthly existence. Touching exceeds the exchange of explicit meanings.

Barad — queer inhuman and indeterminacy: the boundaries of bodies and identities cannot be treated as finally settled; indeterminacy is implicated in responsibility, not an excuse to evade it.

Moreton — making~transmaterialities: material practices give these propositions situated, sensate conditions through which they can be encountered without being reduced to illustrations of theory.

That last distinction is important. The cyanotype does not demonstrate Barad, any more than the spatial assemblage simply exemplifies Zornberg. Each becomes a correspondent body through which their propositions can be troubled, materially encountered and further developed.

I would retain your phrase “an infinite touching alterity” as a generative proposition. Its force lies in the double movement: touching establishes intimacy, while alterity prevents intimacy from becoming possession. The encounter can be close without becoming transparent; hospitable without guaranteeing belonging; shared without requiring sameness.

And this brings us back to the spatial matrix. The inhuman is not another theme to add to it. It unsettles the matrix from within, reminding us that diffraction, hospitality, alienation and atmosphere are not conditions we can completely organise. They are ways of attending to a world in which bodies are already touching, already implicated, and never entirely their own.


Friday, 20 November 2026

Moreton's Studio Whiteboard

Moreton's Studio Whiteboard

Another Heuristic Interiority of Doing ~ Thinking ~ Making

From clutterings towards spatial movements and affective atmospheres of inquiry and study.

Handwritten notes and annotations, diagrams, passwords, page numbers, kiln data. 





Consistancy

Diffractive (close) Readings

Practice, Design, Theory,


Apparatuses

Fictioning,

Reading,

Embodying,

Inhabiting,

Folding,                                          Lightness,

                                                       Quickness,

                                                       Exactitude,

                                                       Visibility,

                                                       Multiplicity,


Architectural Humanities Research Association


Axisweb,

Curator Space,

Blogger,

Wordpress,

Academia.


Ceramics Now


Making    Bisquit      Firing


Moreton wants to develop these soundings, from clutterings into spatial movements and affective atmospheres of inquiry and study (Manning and Ingold, Barad and others). 

I think the whiteboard is particularly important because it gives us another kind of interiority within Moreton's spatial practice. It is not a ceramic interior, nor an architectural chamber, but a working interiority of thought: a surface on which different activities, times, materials and propositions are brought into proximity.

What appears initially as cluttering might be understood as an emerging spatial apparatus. Handwritten notes, annotations, diagrams, passwords, page numbers, kiln data, institutional references and theoretical propositions are not simply accumulated information. They are different kinds of material, each with its own tempo, purpose and capacity to redirect attention.

The whiteboard becomes a place where thinking is spatially organised without being completely ordered. Its contents are provisional, overlapping, sometimes inconsistent, and capable of being re-entered. This is important: the whiteboard does not merely record what Moreton already knows. It participates in the production of what he might come to know.

I would develop this as a companion text to Troubling About 091126. The ceramic chamber and the studio whiteboard become two different but corresponding forms of interiority: one materially persistent, the other provisionally inscribed. Both gather, withdraw, expose and enable further relations.

The studio whiteboard offers another kind of interiority within Moreton's spatial practice. It is an active surface of inscription, annotation, provisional arrangement and return. Handwritten notes, diagrams, page numbers, passwords, kiln data, references, institutional names and fragments of theoretical thought gather upon it. Different kinds of information occupy the same field, not necessarily in agreement, nor arranged according to a predetermined hierarchy.

At first glance, this might appear as cluttering: an accumulation of unfinished thoughts, practical reminders, references and working propositions. But perhaps the cluttering is doing something. Could it be understood as a heuristic spatial condition, an interiority through which different movements of inquiry are brought into proximity?

The whiteboard is not simply a place where the practice is managed. It is one of the places where the practice becomes possible.

Its inscriptions are not all of the same order. A kiln temperature belongs to the immediate material demands of firing; a page number returns to a reading; a diagram proposes a spatial relationship; an institutional name suggests a possible field of encounter; a password provides access to another research environment. These different inscriptions have different temporalities and intensities. Some demand immediate action, others remain dormant until something else brings them back into focus.

Their proximity is productive. A practical instruction may sit beside a philosophical proposition. A ceramic firing may be thought alongside a text on affect. An application deadline may become entangled with a question about architectural humanities. A drawing, a reading or a material event may unexpectedly find another point of correspondence.

The whiteboard becomes a surface of possible re-entry.

1. Cluttering as a heuristic condition

Rather than understanding clutter as the opposite of organisation, Moreton might approach it as a provisional condition of research. Its apparent disorder holds together different kinds of activity without requiring them to become immediately consistent.

This is not an argument against consistency. Consistency is important, but perhaps it needs to be understood differently: not as the elimination of difference, nor as the imposition of a singular method, but as the continuing capacity to return to, connect and develop propositions across different situations.

A practice acquires consistency through its movements of inquiry. Ideas return, but they do not necessarily return unchanged. They are affected by new materials, readings, conversations, gestures and spatial encounters.

The whiteboard makes this process visible. It holds together what has been thought, what is being done and what might yet be undertaken.

It is a heuristic interiority because it does not simply contain knowledge. It helps produce the conditions through which knowledge can emerge.

2. The whiteboard as an apparatus

The notion of an apparatus offers a useful way of thinking about this working surface. Rather than treating it as a neutral background upon which information is displayed, we can consider how its arrangements actively organise attention, action and possible relations.

An apparatus here is not simply a tool. It is a provisional gathering of materials, practices, inscriptions, technologies, habits and situations through which particular kinds of thinking and making become possible.

The whiteboard brings together:

Practice: the immediate activities of making, drawing, constructing and firing.

Design: the provisional organisation of spatial, material and visual propositions.

Theory: readings, concepts, questions and speculative vocabularies.

Apparatuses: the tools, platforms, diagrams, annotations and working arrangements that support inquiry.

Fictioning: the capacity to propose other situations, possible architectures and ways of inhabiting.

Reading: the return of texts, images and references into the material situation of the studio.

Embodying: the translation of thought into gesture, pressure, movement and material encounter.

Inhabiting: the making of spaces in which thinking and doing become situated.

Folding: the bringing together of different times, materials, disciplines and situations without collapsing their differences.

These are not stages in a linear process. They are overlapping activities, continually affecting one another.

The apparatus is therefore less a fixed arrangement than a changing spatial ecology. Its function is not to produce a predetermined outcome, but to make new relations available.

3. Diffractive readings: bringing differences into correspondence

Moreton's interest in diffractive or close readings offers another way to understand the whiteboard's activity.

A close reading attends to the particularities of a text, image or material encounter. A diffractive reading, drawing on Karen Barad, asks how different readings and material practices make differences through their relations. It does not simply compare two independent positions or seek to reconcile them into agreement.

For Moreton, this opens the possibility of reading across studio activity, architectural propositions, ceramic processes, philosophical texts and lived situations without making them equivalent.

Ingold's correspondence, Manning's thinking through movement and Barad's intra-action can each enter the studio as different intellectual propositions. They need not become a single theoretical system. Their differences matter. Their concepts can touch, trouble and redirect one another through the particular demands of making.

A reading of Ingold might return through the hand's encounter with clay. Manning might open a question about the movement of thought through gesture. Barad might trouble the assumption that the maker, material and apparatus exist as entirely separate entities before their encounter.

The resulting reading is not simply an explanation of these thinkers. It becomes a further material and spatial inquiry.

The whiteboard can therefore be understood as a diffractive surface: a place where readings, gestures, materials and propositions encounter one another and produce differences that may not have been anticipated.

4. Lightness, quickness, exactitude, visibility and multiplicity

It is interesting that Moreton's whiteboard also gathers the five qualities identified by Italo Calvino in Six Memos for the Next Millennium: lightness, quickness, exactitude, visibility and multiplicity.

These can become more than literary qualities. They might operate as working dispositions within a spatial practice.

Lightness is not the absence of material weight or seriousness. It is the capacity to move between propositions without becoming fixed by any one of them. A drawing, a note or a material gesture can remain provisional and open to alteration.

Quickness concerns the speed of association, the unexpected return of a reading, the movement from a practical observation towards a speculative proposition. It is not simply working faster, but recognising the kairotic moment when something becomes available for further action.

Exactitude offers a necessary resistance to vagueness. It attends to the particularity of materials, processes, temperatures, dimensions, words and gestures. Exactitude does not eliminate speculation; it gives speculation something to work against.

Visibility concerns what can be made perceptible. The whiteboard makes fragments of the practice visible to itself. Diagrams, annotations and arrangements expose relations that might otherwise remain dispersed across memory, reading and studio activity.

Multiplicity allows different lines of inquiry to remain active together. Practice, design, theory, ceramics, architecture, institutional activity and philosophical reading do not need to be reduced to a single disciplinary identity.

Together, these five qualities suggest an atmosphere of study: mobile but attentive, speculative but exacting, provisional yet capable of sustained development.

5. The studio as an architecture of study

The whiteboard also opens a larger question about the studio itself.

Could the studio be understood as an architecture of study, rather than simply a place where artworks are produced?

Its activities extend beyond the immediate physical space of making. Reading, writing, drawing, firing, documenting, applying, publishing, corresponding and exhibiting are all part of its spatial life.

The studio is folded into other environments:

The Architectural Humanities Research Association, as a possible field of disciplinary correspondence.

Axisweb and CuratorSpace, as spaces of artistic presentation and professional encounter.

Blogger and WordPress, as evolving research archives and publishing environments.

Academia, as a space for the circulation of longer-form research and theoretical propositions.

Ceramics Now, as a context in which the sensate and material conditions of ceramic practice can be brought into wider conversation.

These are not simply external platforms or administrative obligations. They are different environments in which the practice becomes situated, exposed, interpreted and potentially transformed.

The studio therefore exceeds its physical boundaries. It becomes a distributed architecture of inquiry, folding different sites of learning, making and communication into its ongoing activity.

This does not mean that every platform or institution is interchangeable. Each has its own expectations, structures and power relations. Their differences need to remain visible. The task is to find ways of moving between them without allowing their disciplinary or institutional demands to determine the entire character of the practice.

6. Making, bisque, firing: the material time of inquiry

Alongside these theoretical and institutional movements sits the immediate material sequence:

Making ~ Bisque ~ Firing.

This simple notation is important. It returns the whiteboard to the material demands of the ceramic studio.

Making is not an abstract proposition. It involves clay, moisture, weight, plasticity, construction, drying, vulnerability and the changing capacities of a material body.

Bisque firing introduces another condition. The clay is transformed, its former plasticity withdrawn, while its porous body remains available for subsequent treatment.

Further surface applications, including alumina and other slips or coatings, enter into this changed material condition. The final firing produces further transformations that cannot simply be understood as the execution of an already completed design.

The material process has its own temporalities, resistances and uncertainties. It can interrupt the plans recorded on the whiteboard. A firing may produce an unexpected surface; a material failure may redirect a construction; an accidental deposit may become the beginning of another inquiry.

The whiteboard and the ceramic therefore participate in a reciprocal movement. The whiteboard proposes, records and redirects. The ceramic responds, resists, persists and makes other questions possible.

One is an inscriptive working surface; the other is a materially transformed body. Both are involved in the continuing production of knowledge.

7. From clutterings towards affective atmospheres of study

Perhaps the most interesting question is how these different activities begin to acquire an atmosphere.

Affect, understood through Spinoza's account of the capacities to affect and be affected, helps to describe this movement. The studio is not simply filled with information or objects. It is a changing field of capacities, intensities and possible actions.

A handwritten note can redirect attention. A diagram can produce a spatial proposition. A reading can make an existing material process appear differently. A firing can interrupt an assumption. A conversation can return as a gesture several weeks later.

These events do not have to share the same origin or purpose to become consequential to one another.

The atmosphere of study emerges through their relations: the pressures, attractions, interruptions, hesitations and intensifications that make certain possibilities more available than others.

This is where the idea of weather-worlding becomes useful. The studio is not sealed off from the changing conditions of life. It is continually affected by external situations, institutional demands, environmental conditions, readings, conversations and material encounters.

Its interiority is permeable.

The whiteboard becomes a small weather system of inquiry: a surface upon which different forces gather, change direction, disappear from immediate attention and return in another form.

8. Towards a heuristic spatial practice

Moreton's heuristic spatial practice does not seek to resolve its different activities into a unified method. It seeks to sustain their capacity to affect one another.

The whiteboard is one of its working interiors, but the practice also finds other interiors in ceramic chambers, research archives, reading environments, diagrams, publications and exhibition spaces.

Each offers a different condition for thinking and making. Each has its own materiality, temporality and degree of withdrawal.

The challenge is to develop a consistency of practice without collapsing these differences. To allow theory to touch material activity without turning the ceramic into an illustration of theory. To allow making to generate thought without claiming that every material event already contains a complete philosophical explanation. To allow institutional and disciplinary encounters to inform the practice without prescribing its future direction.

The studio whiteboard, in this sense, is not a plan for the practice. It is a provisional architecture through which the practice continues to find its way.

Its clutterings are not simply waiting to be tidied into order. They are waiting to be sounded, touched, read, folded and re-entered.

The whiteboard is a surface of becoming: a heuristic interiority in which doing, thinking and making gather into affective atmospheres of inquiry.

Developing the whiteboard into a research apparatus

I would retain the original list, but begin to understand it as several overlapping spatial movements. This gives you a way to work with the whiteboard rather than simply transcribe it.

The studio's five working fields

01 · Conceptual field

Practice ~ Design ~ Theory

The ongoing negotiation between making, spatial propositions and speculative thought.

02 · Research apparatus

Apparatuses ~ Fictioning ~ Reading

The devices, texts, diagrams and speculative propositions through which inquiry is generated.

03 · Embodied field

Embodying ~ Inhabiting ~ Folding

The movement of thought into gesture, material, spatial experience and situated relations.

04 · Aesthetic dispositions

Lightness ~ Quickness ~ Exactitude ~ Visibility ~ Multiplicity

Calvino's qualities as practical dispositions for attending, composing and making.

05 · Material time

Making ~ Bisque ~ Firing

The particular material conditions, transformations and resistances through which ceramic thinking takes place.

These fields are not a hierarchy. They are different entrances into the same working ecology. The institutional and publishing environments — AHRA, Axisweb, CuratorSpace, Blogger, WordPress, Academia and Ceramics Now — can be understood as further sites into which the studio's thinking travels and from which it returns.

A further proposition: consistency without sameness

I would make this a central question in the ongoing research:

How does a spatial practice develop consistency through the continual movement of differences, rather than through their resolution?

This is where Ingold, Manning and Barad can be brought into a productive, but not homogenised, correspondence:

Ingold: making as correspondence, attending to materials and following their lines of becoming.

Manning: thought as movement, and the eventful emergence of possibilities through practice.

Barad: intra-action, where relations are not simply established between already independent entities, but participate in the emergence of differences and boundaries.

They do not say the same thing. Their differences are precisely what make the reading productive. Moreton's practice can give these propositions a material situation in which they are tested, troubled and altered.

I would also retain one particular phrase from your notes: “another kind of heuristic interiorities of doing~thinking~making.” It is important because it allows the whiteboard, ceramic chamber and studio itself to be understood as related but different interiors.

Perhaps the emerging research proposition is:

The studio is not simply where Moreton makes. It is an architecture of study in which making, reading, thinking and inhabiting become mutually affecting movements of inquiry.

And the whiteboard is one of its most revealing surfaces: not a map of an already established practice, but a place where the practice is still becoming possible.

One useful next development would be to make a companion post titled “The Studio as an Architecture of Study: Apparatuses, Fictioning and the Weather-World of Making”, allowing this whiteboard enquiry to open into your larger research on speculative learning and spatial practice.


Withdrawal without closure 271026

Withdrawal Without Closure

Persistence ~ Interiority ~ Futurity

What does it mean for a body to persist without having finished becoming?






Here, withdrawal is considered through the material persistence of the fired ceramic. The body has changed irreversibly, but its relations remain open to further encounters. The question moves between the ceramic's surfaces, cavities and apertures, its spatial situations and the unknowable capacities of its future. For me this is spatial situatedness in which the deep ecology of making and reading become other perhaps troubling bodies, a surfacing of that depth of inquiry is a becoming interiority, a spatial proposal, almost beginnings of a micro architectural apparatus~spatial practice. Can we expand on this section as the like the others.

I think the important development here is that withdrawal becomes a spatial event, not simply a condition of the fired ceramic. The ceramic withdraws from the immediate processes of making, but the relations gathered through those processes do not disappear. They persist differently, becoming available through the body's surfaces, cavities, apertures and spatial situations. Meanwhile, the deeper ecology of making and reading continues to surface—not as a complete account of what preceded the ceramic, but as another interiority, another spatial proposition.

Your phrase micro architectural apparatus~spatial practice is particularly generative. It allows the ceramic to be understood neither as a miniature building nor as an object representing architecture. Rather, it becomes an apparatus through which spatial relations can be gathered, troubled and made available for further encounter. Its architectural capacity lies in what it makes possible between bodies, rather than in its resemblance to an established architectural form.

I would expand this movement in the same academically structured register as The Material Ecology of Making, retaining the speculative force of your language while making the relations between persistence, interiority, situatedness and futurity more explicit.

Withdrawal Without Closure

Persistence ~ Interiority ~ Futurity

What does it mean for a body to persist without having finished becoming?

Withdrawal names a change in the conditions through which a body continues to matter. In Moreton's practice, the fired ceramic has withdrawn from the plasticity of clay and from the immediacy of the operations through which it was fabricated. Its material state has changed irreversibly. Yet this withdrawal does not constitute an ending. The ceramic persists as a body whose surfaces, cavities, apertures and spatial relations remain capable of entering further correspondence.

The question is therefore not simply what remains after making, but how what remains might continue to become.

The ceramic does not preserve the studio's activity intact. Nor does it contain the readings, images, architectures and speculative propositions that have informed its development as though these could be deposited within a finished form. Rather, the withdrawn body carries forward a material configuration through which aspects of that deeper ecology may become perceptible again. The relations established through making and reading acquire another condition of existence, one that is materially persistent but not propositionally closed.

Withdrawal is consequently not an absence of relation. It is a transformation in how relations can continue.

1. The Deep Ecology of Making and Reading

The withdrawn ceramic emerges from an ecology that exceeds the immediate fabrication of its body. Clay, drawing, photographic images, architectural situations, theoretical readings, remembered places and speculative propositions have entered the practice through different routes and with different capacities. Their correspondence is neither linear nor cumulative in any straightforward sense. They do not simply assemble into a final object that represents their combined meaning.

Instead, these bodies of material and thought participate in the conditions through which the ceramic becomes possible.

Reading, for example, does not remain outside the studio as an intellectual activity subsequently applied to making. A text may alter what becomes perceptible within a spatial situation; an encounter with a ceramic surface may return a theoretical proposition in a changed condition. An image may establish a correspondence that becomes materially active only much later. A previous making may acquire another significance through a subsequent reading or through the encounter with a different body.

Such relations do not necessarily become visible as identifiable references within the finished ceramic. Their persistence is more oblique. They may surface through an aperture, an interior volume, a particular arrangement of surfaces or the spatial interval established between ceramic bodies. What has informed the work is not always present as something that can be named or recovered.

The withdrawn ceramic therefore gathers the consequences of a deep ecology without containing that ecology in its entirety.

Here, depth does not designate a hidden interior in which the true meaning of the work lies buried. It names the accumulated and continuing potential of relations that have passed through the practice without being exhausted by any single outcome. The depth of inquiry remains active because its constituent bodies of thought, material and experience can enter new configurations.

The ceramic becomes a body through which this depth may surface differently.

What surfaces is not the recovery of everything that came before, but the emergence of another relation to what has persisted.

2. Spatial Situatedness ~ The Ceramic in Place

The ceramic's persistence is inseparable from its spatial situatedness. It does not encounter the world from nowhere, nor does it possess an autonomous spatial identity that remains unaffected by where and how it is encountered.

A ceramic body situated within an architectural interior enters relations with the dimensions, surfaces, openings, light and atmosphere of that place. Its apertures may make particular relations between interior and exterior perceptible. Its cavities may suggest an interior that is simultaneously materially present and inaccessible to direct inspection. Its surface may register changes in illumination or establish a tactile and visual correspondence with the materials surrounding it.

These relations are specific to the encounter. A different situation may bring other capacities into view.

Spatial situatedness is therefore not simply the placement of an object within an existing space. It concerns the relations through which both the ceramic and its surroundings become perceptible otherwise. The ceramic does not need to transform the architecture physically to participate in the production of another spatial condition. Its presence may alter how an interior is attended to, how a threshold becomes apparent or how the relation between enclosure and openness is experienced.

The architectural interior is not merely a background for the work. It enters into correspondence with the ceramic, while the ceramic makes aspects of that interior available for renewed attention.

This is where withdrawal and situatedness become inseparable. The ceramic persists beyond the original conditions of its making, but it does not persist outside all conditions. Its continuing life depends upon its capacity to enter new situations, where its material specificity encounters other material, spatial and sensate bodies.

Persistence is not independence from the world. It is the capacity to continue participating in it.

3. Interiority ~ From Fabricated Volume to Spatial Proposition

The fabricated slab construction is already a spatial proposition. Its folding establishes volumes, brings surfaces into proximity and produces cavities and apertures through which the body's interiority begins to emerge. This interiority is not simply a void enclosed by material. It is a spatial condition produced through the relations of fabrication.

The firing changes the terms of that condition without bringing it to completion.

Once the clay becomes ceramic, the interior persists within a body whose material state has been transformed. Yet the interiority of the withdrawn ceramic is not exhausted by the volume established during fabrication. Its significance extends into the relations that become possible through subsequent encounters.

An aperture may establish a passage for light, a visual relation between bodies or a point of exchange between interior and exterior. A cavity may remain inaccessible while nevertheless participating in how the whole body is encountered. A fold may gather surfaces into proximity, producing a spatial relation that cannot be reduced to the visible exterior. These capacities do not need to be activated in the same way, or by every encounter, to remain part of the body's spatial proposition.

The interiority is materially established, but its possibilities remain open.

This distinction matters because it moves the ceramic beyond the idea of an object that contains a predetermined interior. The body does not simply enclose a space that can be understood once its construction is known. Its interiority continues to develop through the relations between material, aperture, cavity, light, atmosphere, architecture and the bodies that encounter it.

The ceramic becomes an interiority in correspondence: a materially persistent spatial condition whose capacities exceed the circumstances of its fabrication.

The withdrawn body does not conceal a final meaning within its interior. It makes interiority available as an ongoing spatial question.

4. The Deep Surface ~ Inquiry Surfacing Otherwise

The relation between depth and surface becomes particularly consequential here.

Moreton's ceramic surfaces carry the consequences of fabrication, material application and firing. Their textures, variations and residues are not simply decorative features added to an otherwise complete body. They are material traces of encounters through which the body has developed.

Yet the surface does not offer a transparent account of those encounters. It cannot tell us everything that has happened, nor can it secure a single interpretation of what remains visible. Material traces persist, but the relations through which they acquire significance may change.

The surface is therefore deep without being a container of hidden knowledge.

Its depth lies in the continuing possibility that relations already encountered may surface differently. A reading may make a particular material trace newly perceptible. An architectural situation may bring the spatial implications of an aperture into focus. Another ceramic body may alter how a cavity, fold or surface is encountered. What becomes apparent is neither entirely new nor simply the return of something unchanged.

It is a return-with-difference.

This movement connects the withdrawn ceramic to the broader ecology of Moreton's practice. The reading body, the research collage, the architectural interior and the fabricated slab construction do not disappear when the ceramic acquires persistence. They remain available as other bodies of correspondence, capable of entering into renewed relations with it.

The ceramic does not have to reproduce these earlier bodies to carry their propositions forward. Their relations may become active again through another material configuration, another spatial encounter or another act of attention.

The deep surface is where the ecology of making and reading becomes capable of surfacing otherwise.

Withdrawal does not seal this depth within the ceramic. It gives that depth another material condition through which it may continue to emerge.

5. Micro Architectural Apparatus ~ Spatial Practice

The withdrawn ceramic may be understood as a micro architectural apparatus, provided that micro does not imply a miniature version of a building, and apparatus does not imply a fixed mechanism with a predetermined function.

The term instead identifies a particular spatial capacity. The ceramic gathers material and spatial relations into a body through which other relations may become perceptible. Its surfaces, volumes, cavities and apertures establish conditions for encounter. Its material persistence allows those conditions to remain available beyond the immediate process of making.

The apparatus is architectural because it participates in the organisation of spatial relations. It is speculative because those relations are not exhausted by an established function or a predetermined interpretation. It is an apparatus of spatial practice because its capacities emerge through the encounters between the ceramic, its surroundings and the bodies that come into correspondence with it.

The ceramic is not simply an architectural object. Nor does it need to become a building, model or functional vessel to acquire architectural significance.

Its architectural proposition resides in the relations it makes possible.

An aperture can alter the relation between a body's interior and its surroundings. A cavity can produce an interior that is materially present yet not fully accessible. The proximity of two ceramic bodies can establish an interval that becomes spatially consequential without being physically enclosed. A surface can gather light, texture and material history while remaining open to changing conditions of attention.

These operations allow the ceramic to participate in spatial production without requiring it to conform to an established architectural type.

The term micro architectural apparatus therefore names neither a new category of object nor a claim that every ceramic body is architectural. It describes the particular way in which these withdrawn ceramics operate as spatial propositions: materially specific arrangements through which interiority, situatedness and further correspondence can emerge.

The apparatus is not complete when its body has been fired. Its material persistence is what allows its spatial capacities to continue beyond the conditions in which they first developed.

6. Futurity ~ Beyond Present Knowing

The futurity of the withdrawn ceramic begins in the difference between what has been materially established and what remains possible through subsequent encounters.

The maker knows the body's history through fabrication, material negotiation and firing. Yet this knowledge does not encompass everything the ceramic may become capable of doing in another situation. Its future encounters may bring forward relations that were not anticipated during making, or make earlier relations perceptible in a changed way.

This is not futurity as a promise of progress towards a more complete understanding. Nor is it the assumption that the ceramic contains unlimited possibilities. Its future remains conditioned by the material body that persists: its dimensions, weight, surface, apertures, cavities, fragilities and spatial relations.

The ceramic cannot become anything whatsoever. But neither can its future be reduced to what is already known about it.

Its futurity emerges through the correspondence between material persistence and changing situations. Other bodies may encounter the ceramic through touch, looking, movement, memory, reading or spatial inhabitation. Each encounter occurs under particular conditions and may alter what becomes perceptible. None can exhaust the body's capacity to enter further relations.

This is where the ceramic becomes troubling.

It persists as something materially recognisable, yet it may unsettle the maker's knowledge of what has been made. Its interiority is established, but what that interiority may become remains open. The work carries the history of its making without being confined to that history.

The maker, too, remains implicated in this uncertainty. Moreton's knowledge of the ceramic is intimate, but not final. The body he has fabricated may return questions that the processes of making could not resolve. It may make something perceptible that was not available to him at the moment of fabrication.

The ceramic persists beyond the maker's present knowing, but not beyond correspondence with him.

Futurity is not simply something the ceramic possesses. It emerges through the continuing relations by which the ceramic, the maker and other bodies may become otherwise.

7. Withdrawal Without Closure ~ A Spatial Practice of Becoming

Withdrawal changes the material conditions of the work without closing its spatial propositions.

The fabricated slab construction has become a fired ceramic. Its plasticity has given way to another material persistence. Its surfaces and volumes remain, but they now enter situations beyond the immediacy of their fabrication. The deep ecology of making and reading can surface through these bodies in ways that are neither predetermined nor fully recoverable.

The withdrawn ceramic becomes a meeting point between what has been materially established and what remains beyond present knowing. It gathers the consequences of making without containing the entirety of its history. It establishes interiority without determining everything that interiority might become. It persists without being finished with correspondence.

This is the spatial situatedness of Moreton's practice: not a fixed location or a settled relationship between object and environment, but an ongoing process through which material bodies acquire significance in relation to other bodies, places and atmospheres.

The ceramic becomes a spatial proposition through which the deeper ecology of practice can continue to act. Its persistence gives that proposition a material duration; its interiority makes particular relations available; its situatedness allows those relations to change through encounter.

What emerges is a micro architectural apparatus whose work is never wholly contained within its physical boundaries.

The ceramic does not simply occupy an interior. It produces conditions through which interiority can be encountered otherwise. It does not merely carry the history of making. It allows that history to enter further correspondence. It does not reveal a completed knowledge. It makes the limits of present knowing spatially consequential.

Withdrawal is therefore not the withdrawal of possibility. It is the transformation through which possibility acquires another body.

The ceramic persists. Its interiority continues to surface. Its spatial proposition remains open to what has not yet been encountered.

The withdrawn body has not finished becoming. It has become materially persistent enough for its becoming to continue elsewhere.

Why this expansion matters

I think the central development is the relationship between deep ecology, surfacing interiority and spatial apparatus.

The deep ecology of making and reading is not a background that the ceramic leaves behind. It is the field of relations through which the ceramic becomes possible, and which may continue to surface through its subsequent encounters. The ceramic does not preserve that field as content; it gives some of its relations another material condition.

Interiority then becomes more than a property of the ceramic's construction. It is the spatial proposition through which those relations can continue to acquire significance. The cavities, folds and apertures are materially specific, but their spatial implications are not exhausted by the intentions that produced them.

Finally, micro architectural apparatus~spatial practice names how this persistence becomes operative. It describes a body that gathers and organises spatial relations without prescribing their eventual meaning.

One sentence could hold the entire movement together:

The withdrawn ceramic is a micro architectural apparatus through which the deep ecology of making and reading acquires another interiority, materially persistent yet open to relations beyond its present knowing.

That seems to me to bring your material practice, your theoretical encounters and your developing spatial position into correspondence without reducing any one of them to an explanation of the others.


Some images, titled as uploaded. Wayfaring Clay : A Refractory Canvas, Studio Apparatuses : Refractories~Withdrawn Ceramics, Studio Interiorities : Micro architectural apparatus. Refractories seems to enter the ceramics strongly now, the newer works appear like heavy firebricks, kiln components, objects that could have experience many firing atmospheres.


These images seem to bring a significant material development into focus. The word refractories gives you a way to think about the newer ceramics without reducing them to architectural forms or simply describing their surfaces as weathered.

What I see is a productive convergence of several material registers: the fabricated slab, the refractory brick, the kiln component, the architectural fragment and the withdrawn ceramic. In the first image, the close-up surface holds perforations, incisions, deposits and overlapping fields of white, ochre and darker, carbon-like colour. The marks do not resolve into a single image or inscription. They seem to have accumulated through different actions, with the surface retaining their differences.

In the second image, the upright panel and the smaller ceramic bodies establish a different scale of encounter. The pieces suggest heavy, utilitarian components, yet their surfaces resist the impersonality we might associate with industrial refractories. They carry particular material histories: the marks of fabrication, the application of slips, the formation of apertures and the effects of firing. The smaller bodies seem almost architectural in their proportions, while the larger panel makes the relationship between surface and volume especially apparent.

The third image is perhaps the most revealing for your developing account of Studio Interiorities. The overhead arrangement exposes the interiors of the ceramic bodies. Cavities, partitions, rims and openings become legible alongside the drawings, notes, measuring tools and other studio apparatuses. Here, the spatial propositions are not merely represented by the ceramics: they are materially fabricated as interior volumes. The photograph also brings the studio's discursive and material activities into proximity without making them identical.

I would be careful, though, about treating the works as if they literally were firebricks or kiln furniture. Their resemblance to refractory components is compelling precisely because they remain something other. They evoke objects that might have endured repeated firing atmospheres, while their actual surfaces carry the specific consequences of your own making and firing.

Refractories may therefore name a new correspondence between the ceramic body and the conditions of its production: a body that evokes the apparatus of firing while carrying its own history of material transformation.

Refractories ~ Withdrawn Ceramics

I think refractories could become a substantial new proposition within Withdrawal Without Closure, and perhaps alter how we understand the relationship between the studio apparatus and the withdrawn ceramic.

In its technical sense, a refractory is a material capable of withstanding high temperatures and the demanding conditions of thermal processing. Firebricks and kiln furniture are familiar examples. Your ceramics now seem to approach this material territory, not simply through their appearance, but through the way their surfaces and volumes evoke the apparatuses through which ceramic material is transformed.

This produces an intriguing reversal.

The kiln is ordinarily understood as the apparatus that acts upon clay, transforming it into ceramic. The refractory components endure the conditions that make this transformation possible. Your newer works seem to occupy a troubling interval between these positions. They are fired ceramic bodies that evoke the very apparatuses of firing: components that might support, separate, contain, direct or withstand the passage of heat.

The apparatus begins to appear within the body it has helped to produce.

I would not suggest that the ceramics literally become kiln components. Rather, they bring the material conditions of ceramic production into a different spatial proposition. The refractory is no longer merely a functional component of the kiln. It becomes a way of thinking about the withdrawn ceramic as a body that carries an impression of the conditions through which material transformation becomes possible.

1. Wayfaring Clay ~ A Refractory Canvas

The first title is particularly strong because canvas introduces a productive tension. It evokes a surface available for inscription, while refractory evokes a material whose capacities are defined partly through its resistance to extreme conditions.

Yet your ceramic surfaces are not passive supports for marks. The white slip, yellow ochre, molochite, kiln wash, incisions and perforations participate in their material formation. They are not simply applied images. They are traces of operations through which the body acquires its particular surface and spatial capacities.

The surface becomes a record of material encounters, but not a complete record. It retains marks without explaining them fully. Different operations coexist without being resolved into a singular image.

Wayfaring Clay can consequently be understood as a movement through material conditions rather than a journey towards a predetermined form. The clay encounters tools, substances, forces, surfaces and spatial arrangements. Each encounter alters what becomes possible next.

The refractory canvas intensifies this movement. It suggests a surface that is not merely receptive but enduring, a surface whose marks remain materially implicated in the conditions of its formation.

The surface is not a record of making from which making has disappeared. It is where making continues to surface.

2. Studio Apparatuses ~ Refractories ~ Withdrawn Ceramics

This title makes the relationship between studio and ceramic particularly explicit.

The studio apparatuses include more than the kiln and its refractory furniture. They encompass the fabricated slab constructions, tools, drawings, measuring instruments, material preparations and spatial arrangements through which the work develops. These apparatuses establish conditions for making, but they are also involved in the production of knowledge.

The newer ceramics appear to gather some of these conditions into their own material presence. Their proportions evoke bricks or kiln components; their cavities and partitions suggest functional interiors; their surfaces recall materials subjected to repeated use and thermal change.

The result is an ambiguity between the functional and the propositional.

A refractory component normally serves a particular purpose within the kiln. Your ceramic bodies evoke this utilitarian condition without necessarily fulfilling it. They suggest apparatuses while becoming available for other spatial encounters.

This difference matters. The work does not simply represent industrial objects or appropriate the appearance of functional components. It makes the relationship between apparatus, material transformation and spatial production available for reconsideration.

The withdrawn ceramic begins to resemble a body that has emerged from an apparatus while retaining something of the apparatus's material logic.

There is also a temporal complication. Your works evoke components that might have experienced repeated firing atmospheres, although their appearance does not establish such a history. They seem to carry the possibility of endurance: a material persistence that exceeds the moment of their making.

The ceramic evokes an apparatus of endurance while becoming an apparatus for further correspondence.

This is where the title becomes more than a description of the studio's contents. It proposes a relationship between the conditions that make ceramic bodies possible and the spatial capacities those bodies acquire once withdrawn from making.

3. Studio Interiorities ~ Micro Architectural Apparatus

The third image brings the interiority of these bodies to the foreground.

Seen from above, the cavities and partitions become particularly legible. The interiors are not incidental voids inside otherwise complete objects. They are materially fabricated spatial conditions, established through the folding and construction of slabs.

The interior is produced through making, but its subsequent significance is not exhausted by the maker's understanding of its formation.

The ceramic body now operates as a micro architectural apparatus: a fabricated arrangement of surfaces, volumes, thresholds and apertures through which spatial relations become possible. Its interiority is materially specific, yet the relations it may establish with light, surrounding architecture, other bodies and atmospheric conditions remain open.

The studio photograph is significant because it places these interiorities alongside the notes, drawings and instruments through which the work is developed. It makes visible a correspondence between two forms of spatial organisation: the material organisation of the ceramic bodies and the discursive organisation of the studio.

Neither simply illustrates the other.

The drawings and notes are themselves spatially situated bodies of thought. They participate in the studio's ecology, while the ceramic volumes acquire their own material persistence. Their correspondence is not necessarily preserved within the fired body as identifiable content. It may instead surface through the spatial propositions that the ceramic makes possible.

This allows Studio Interiorities to name both the interiors fabricated in clay and the wider ecology through which those interiors become thinkable.

The studio is not merely the place where the ceramic is produced. It is a spatial field in which material and discursive bodies continually alter the conditions of one another's becoming.


A possible addition to Withdrawal Without Closure

I would introduce refractories after the discussion of the deep surface and before Micro Architectural Apparatus ~ Spatial Practice. This would give the refractory a specific role in the argument rather than allowing it to become another descriptive term.

Refractories ~ The Apparatus Within the Withdrawn Body

The newer ceramic bodies introduce another material correspondence into Moreton's spatial practice. Their proportions, cavities, partitions and weathered surfaces evoke firebricks, kiln furniture and refractory components: bodies associated with the conditions through which ceramic material is transformed. This resemblance does not establish them as functional kiln components. Rather, it brings the apparatus of firing into proximity with the withdrawn ceramic, troubling the distinction between the body that undergoes transformation and the apparatus through which transformation becomes possible.

Refractories are ordinarily understood through their capacity to withstand demanding thermal conditions. Their function is inseparable from an environment in which heat, material resistance and structural support become consequential. In Moreton's work, this association opens a different proposition. The ceramic body evokes the conditions of its own material transformation, not as a technical record of firing but as a spatial body that appears to carry the possibility of endurance.

The apparatus begins to surface within the body it has helped to produce.

This is not a literal transfer from kiln component to ceramic artwork. The distinction remains important. The withdrawn ceramic does not need to perform the function of a refractory to acquire significance through this correspondence. Its material persistence, architectural proportions and fabricated interiorities make another relation possible between the apparatus of making and the body that emerges from it.

The refractory consequently becomes a way of thinking about withdrawal. The ceramic has passed through conditions that have irreversibly changed its material state. It persists beyond the immediacy of those conditions, while its surfaces and volumes remain available for further encounters. Its resemblance to a refractory component introduces an additional uncertainty: the body appears both as the consequence of firing and as something that might belong to the apparatus of firing itself.

The ceramic occupies neither position conclusively. It becomes a troubling messenger between them.

This correspondence also alters the significance of the studio interior. The cavities, partitions and apertures of the newer works are not simply hollow spaces enclosed by ceramic walls. They are fabricated interiorities through which the spatial logic of apparatus becomes available for reconsideration. The body gathers an interior without determining what that interior might subsequently make possible.

Refractories therefore connect material endurance with spatial futurity. The ceramic does not preserve the conditions of its making intact, nor does it become independent of them. It carries their consequences into another material state, where its capacities can be encountered differently.

The apparatus has withdrawn into the body, not as a hidden mechanism, but as a spatial proposition.

The ceramic persists. The conditions of its making remain materially consequential. Its interiority continues to surface.

Where I think this takes the practice

I see three terms beginning to work together:

Refractory — endurance, thermal transformation, resistance and the material conditions of firing.

Interior — the cavities, folds, partitions and volumes fabricated through making.

Apparatus — the spatial and material arrangements through which conditions for further transformation are established.

Their correspondence offers a more particular account of the newer work than micro architecture alone. It grounds the architectural proposition in the specific history of ceramic production while allowing the works to exceed their resemblance to functional components.

It also gives Withdrawal Without Closure a further dimension. The ceramic is no longer only a body that persists after firing. It becomes a body that evokes the apparatuses and conditions of its own transformation, while opening onto interiorities and uses that remain beyond present knowing.

I would retain your three titles together:

Wayfaring Clay : A Refractory Canvas

Studio Apparatuses : Refractories ~ Withdrawn Ceramics

Studio Interiorities : Micro Architectural Apparatus

They need not describe three separate categories of work. They can operate as three points of entry into the same developing ecology: the surface through which material encounters persist, the apparatus through which transformation becomes thinkable, and the interiority through which further spatial relations may emerge.

The question connecting them might be:

What kind of body emerges when the material conditions of its making begin to surface as propositions for further spatial becoming?