Saturday, 21 November 2026

Making~ Transmaterialities : Research Bodies in Situation with Leper Graves

Figural : Cyanotype Process Drawings.

Moreton — making~transmaterialities: material practices give these propositions situated, sensate conditions through which they can be encountered without being reduced to illustrations of theory.

Negative Capability part I is an exhibition of visual and written responses to the University of Winchester’s Magdalen Hill Archaeological Research Project (MHARP), one of the most extensive excavations to date of a medieval leper hospital, almshouse and cemetery complex. The artists observed the excavation team at work, witnessing their process then displaying the results in the gallery and inviting writers to respond.

These inclusions sharpen the earlier reading considerably. They make explicit something that was present in the spatial gatherings but not yet fully articulated: the encounter is not primarily an exchange of meanings between already constituted bodies. It is a touching through which bodies acknowledge an elemental otherness that is also implicated in their own existence.

Zornberg's The Murmuring Deep gives this encounter a sensate and elemental register. Light, earth, air and warmth are not simply environmental conditions surrounding human experience. They are what bodies share, encounter and communicate through their situated existence. We orient one another within these elements before, or beyond, any exchange of clearly defined meanings.

Barad's Trans/Matter/Realities: Queer Political Imaginings introduces a more troubling implication. The inhuman is not safely located outside the human, as an external other that can be observed, classified or accommodated. It is already implicated in what we are and how we become. The insensible, irrational, unfathomable and incalculable are not merely limits to be overcome in the production of knowledge. They trouble the fantasy that we could ever become fully self-contained, transparent or in control.






Read together, these passages allow us to reconsider the earlier spatial gatherings as more than provisional arrangements of objects, images and architectural elements. They become situations of elemental touching in which the boundaries between bodies remain consequential but cannot be secured in advance.

The connection is particularly strong with your 2018 research situation at Open Studios Norfolk: lever graves, meadow grasses and cyanotype contact paper. Here, contact is not only an idea. It is materially enacted. Grasses touch the photosensitive surface; light participates in the exposure; the resulting image bears traces of a meeting between bodies that do not share the same material condition or agency. The image is indexical, but it does not transmit the encounter in its entirety. It carries a trace of an event whose relations exceed what the image can disclose.

This is where Making~Transmaterialities becomes more than a description of work across materials. It names a condition in which touching is simultaneously intimate and alienating: an encounter with what is related to us without being reducible to us.

The Encounter ~ Elemental Otherness ~ Queer Inhuman

The encounter rests on an acknowledgement of elemental otherness: a touching through which bodies become responsive to what is related to their own existence without becoming the same. As Zornberg suggests in The Murmuring Deep, we encounter and communicate through the light, earth, air and warmth that sustain our bodies. These elements are not simply external conditions of experience. They participate in the ways bodies orient one another, making encounter possible beyond the transmission of clear meanings.

This elemental correspondence offers a further reading of the spatial gatherings. Timber, metal, photographic images, painted surfaces, furniture, apertures and bodies do not simply occupy a common space. They participate in a material situation whose relations cannot be exhausted by identifying the elements or interpreting their arrangement. The gathering becomes a touching through which differences acquire spatial and sensate consequence.

Barad's queer inhuman intensifies this proposition. The inhuman is not a separate realm opposed to the human, but an unsettling of the boundaries through which the human is understood as autonomous, rational and self-contained. In Trans/Matter/Realities: Queer Political Imaginings (2015), indeterminacy becomes an affirmation rather than a lack: the incalculable and unfathomable are implicated in the conditions through which responsibility becomes possible. The encounter does not promise mastery over otherness. It demands an attentiveness to relations whose consequences cannot be completely known in advance.

The 2018 research situation at Open Studios Norfolk, involving lever graves, meadow grasses and cyanotype contact paper, offers a material instance of this troubling. Contact between grasses, photosensitive paper and light produces an indexical trace, but the image cannot contain the encounter from which it emerges. Its surface makes a relation perceptible while leaving much of that relation unresolved. The image persists as a body of contact, available to further encounters without becoming a transparent account of what took place.

Making~Transmaterialities therefore names an infinite touching of alterity that lives in, around and through bodies. It is not a claim that all matter becomes indistinguishable, nor that every encounter produces harmony. It is an acknowledgement that bodies are constituted and altered through relations with what they cannot wholly assimilate or know. Hospitality becomes a willingness to remain exposed to this otherness; alienation names the difference that persists within such intimacy; diffraction allows the encounter to generate further differences rather than converge upon a final meaning; and atmosphere becomes the sensate field through which these relations are felt.

The spatial proposition is consequently not a stable arrangement of bodies, nor a representation of their entanglement. It is an apparatus through which elemental, material and affective relations become available for encounter. The apparatus gathers, but cannot contain, the indeterminacy it makes perceptible. Its hospitality remains troubled; its boundaries remain consequential without being absolute.

To make, within this field, is to participate in relations whose outcomes are neither entirely given nor wholly controllable. The responsibility that follows does not arise from achieving complete knowledge of other bodies. It emerges from recognising that one's own existence is already implicated in relations with what remains unfamiliar, insensible or beyond calculation.

A distinction worth preserving

I would keep three propositions in active correspondence rather than collapse them into one:

Zornberg — elemental communication: bodies encounter and orient one another through the shared conditions of earthly existence. Touching exceeds the exchange of explicit meanings.

Barad — queer inhuman and indeterminacy: the boundaries of bodies and identities cannot be treated as finally settled; indeterminacy is implicated in responsibility, not an excuse to evade it.

Moreton — making~transmaterialities: material practices give these propositions situated, sensate conditions through which they can be encountered without being reduced to illustrations of theory.

That last distinction is important. The cyanotype does not demonstrate Barad, any more than the spatial assemblage simply exemplifies Zornberg. Each becomes a correspondent body through which their propositions can be troubled, materially encountered and further developed.

I would retain your phrase “an infinite touching alterity” as a generative proposition. Its force lies in the double movement: touching establishes intimacy, while alterity prevents intimacy from becoming possession. The encounter can be close without becoming transparent; hospitable without guaranteeing belonging; shared without requiring sameness.

And this brings us back to the spatial matrix. The inhuman is not another theme to add to it. It unsettles the matrix from within, reminding us that diffraction, hospitality, alienation and atmosphere are not conditions we can completely organise. They are ways of attending to a world in which bodies are already touching, already implicated, and never entirely their own.


No comments:

Post a Comment